Proposition 1: A Jewish and Democratic Call for Equal Rights
Among the six ballot measures we will be voting on this election season, BJ is supporting Proposition 1, more commonly known as New York’s Equal Rights Amendment (ERA). This amendment would be a landmark step in expanding civil rights protections in our state constitution.
Why is this a Jewish value?
Proposition 1 represents an important update to the nondiscrimination protections enshrined in New York’s constitution, expanding them for the first time since 1938. The current language only protects against discrimination based on race, color, creed, or religion. If passed, the ERA will expand these protections to include ethnicity, disability, age, national origin, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, pregnancy or pregnancy outcomes, and reproductive health care and autonomy. These changes reflect the evolving understanding of civil rights and justice in a modern society.
Jewish Law on Reproductive Rights
One of the more significant aspects of this proposal is its protection for reproductive health care and autonomy—a right grounded in Jewish values. While the term “abortion” does not appear on the ballot, the amendment’s language referring to pregnancy outcomes and reproductive autonomy does include the right to abortion.
In Judaism, abortion is not only permitted but, in some cases, required when the life or health of the pregnant individual is at risk. “Health” in Jewish law encompasses both physical and psychological well-being. Protecting access to reproductive health care upholds this value, ensuring that individuals can make the best decisions for their health and their families.
Jewish law does not consider a fetus to have the same legal status as a person, affirming that the life of the pregnant individual always takes precedence. This belief underscores why abortion access is essential in preserving human dignity and life. Moreover, as the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution guarantees, no one religion should dictate public policy on issues like abortion, ensuring that every individual retains their right to make personal health decisions.
A Call to Action
As a diverse and multifaceted community, we understand that some of our members may hold different views on this issue. We encourage every New Yorker to read the amendment carefully, engage in conversations with family and friends, and learn about everything on your ballot before voting.
Most importantly, make sure to vote. Our Jewish tradition teaches the importance of civic engagement and the pursuit of justice, and this election is an opportunity to put those values into action.